Tagged: teenage romance
Discussion: Insta-Love
If there’s one thing I hate about YA (and depending on the day, there are multiple things) it’s the fact that all of the main characters seem to fall in Insta-Love. There is, of course, no formal definition for Insta-Love so I usually define it as: “A type of attraction in which the main character becomes obsessed with another character within a short amount of time, usually in under a week. Can result in ridiculous declarations of being ‘soulmates’ or some other variation of the word.”
Okay, I get that you can be very strongly attracted to someone you just met. It’s happened to me before. However, you can’t proclaim ‘love’ on the basis of someone’s looks alone, as seems to happen in YA so much. The (usually) female main character will look at a boy and immediately think of him as ‘cute’, ‘hot’ or ‘handsome’ and spend the next few days mooning over him and generally making a fool of herself. Then, when the boy seems to return her interest, she proclaims that their love is real and everlasting.
Yuck.
Teenage love can be more than a little obsessive because of hormones and a general lack of life experience. But really, not all teenagers are immediately going to fall in love with the nearest good-looking person. That’s why it baffles me why Insta-Love seems to occur in so many YA novels. Of course the polar opposite of Insta-Love is the now cliché Slap-Slap-Kiss when main characters hate each other and then suddenly start making out and proclaiming their love. But that’s a discussion for another time.
Now I want to hear from you: What do you think of Insta-Love? Is it healthy for novelists to portray this as a legitimate type of love when their books are aimed at a teenage audience? Are you as tired of Insta-Love as I am? Or do you think a little Insta-Love is okay?
Discussion: Romance in YA Novels
No, this is not a discussion about whether romance is appropriate for YA novels, but rather a discussion of the romance we already find in YA novels.
I, for one, find most YA romances unbelievable and/or just plain creepy. Yes, I know young love is crazy and even a little clingy, but some books take this to a whole new level. In some novels, we see the male love interests take on qualities I would consider to be borderline abusive or worse: controlling what the main character does, who she talks to, giving her mixed signals constantly, etc. The most notable example is, of course, Twilight. However, I’m still seeing some of these behaviours in mostly male love interests in young adult novels. It’s certainly not sending out any great messages to impressionable teens about what is love and what is not.
The other thing I have a problem with in YA romances is that they’re so unbelievable. I know teenagers are particularly hormonal and romantic, but declarations of love after a week or so are just plain ridiculous. In some books, the main character hardly knows her male love interest before she’s saying she loves him. And when she realizes she loves him, suddenly she can’t live without him and has no interests outside her relationship with him. Is that realistic? Not really. Is that healthy? Definitely not.
Okay, I better stop now or I’ll be ranting all day. Yes, there are some great, healthy relationships in YA (Katniss and Po from Graceling), but the trend of borderline abusive relationships is frankly disturbing to me. But now I want to hear your thoughts on the topic: What do you think of romance in YA novels in general? Are the portrayals of relationships healthy? What is your favourite YA couple? Why?